FOB vs CIF vs EXW for Construction Machinery Export: A Practical Guide for Buyers

The three Incoterms 2020 options that cover almost every cross-border construction-machinery deal — and the four practical questions that decide which one is right for your shipment.

The three Incoterms that matter for machinery

Incoterms 2020 has eleven terms; for used construction machinery, three cover more than 90% of the deals we see: EXW (Ex Works), FOB (Free On Board), and CIF (Cost, Insurance, and Freight). Each one shifts the cost, the risk, and the paperwork between the buyer and the seller in a specific way. The price changes too, and the difference is not just on the invoice.

EXW (Ex Works) — the seller’s simplest option

Under EXW, the buyer takes ownership, risk, and responsibility for the machine the moment it leaves the seller’s warehouse door. The seller’s price covers only the cost of making the machine available at the named place (usually the seller’s yard). The buyer is responsible for: loading the machine onto a truck, inland transport to the port, export customs clearance, ocean freight, marine insurance, and import customs clearance at the destination.

When EXW is the right choice: the buyer has a freight forwarder they trust, has shipped similar equipment before, and is willing to take responsibility for the export-side paperwork. For a buyer in China or for a buyer who has shipped machinery from China many times, EXW is often the cheapest option.

When EXW is the wrong choice: the buyer is new to cross-border machinery, does not have a freight forwarder, or is in a country where Chinese exporters cannot easily clear export customs on the buyer’s behalf. In those cases, the buyer is likely to be quoted a higher inland-freight and export-clearance cost than the seller could have negotiated.

FOB (Free On Board) — the most common machinery term

Under FOB, the seller delivers the machine onto the vessel at the named port of shipment. The seller is responsible for: inland transport to the port, export customs clearance, and loading the machine onto the ship. The risk transfers at the moment the machine is on board. The buyer is responsible for: ocean freight, marine insurance, and import customs clearance at the destination port.

When FOB is the right choice: the buyer has a freight forwarder at the destination port, can arrange marine insurance at competitive rates, and wants to control the ocean leg. FOB is the term we default to at Asure — for a buyer in West Africa, Southeast Asia, or South America, FOB at the Chinese port (Shanghai, Qingdao, Tianjin, Lianyungang) is almost always the cleanest option.

CIF (Cost, Insurance, and Freight) — the buyer’s simplest option

Under CIF, the seller arranges and pays for ocean freight and marine insurance to the named destination port. The risk still transfers at the loading port, but the seller handles the freight and insurance paperwork. The buyer is responsible only for: import customs clearance at the destination, inland transport from the destination port, and any final-mile delivery.

When CIF is the right choice: the buyer is a first-time importer, does not have a freight forwarder, or wants a single all-in price without having to manage the ocean leg. CIF is the term we recommend for buyers who have not shipped from China before, or for buyers in markets where arranging marine insurance locally is difficult or expensive.

The four practical questions that decide the term

1. Do you have a freight forwarder? If yes, FOB or EXW gives you control. If no, CIF means the seller arranges it.

2. What marine insurance is available to you locally? If your local insurer can write a policy at 0.3-0.5% of cargo value, you can insure under FOB and save the seller’s markup. If insurance is hard to arrange, CIF is the right call.

3. How much do you trust the seller’s freight forwarder? Under FOB or CIF, the seller chooses the freight forwarder. A good forwarder costs USD 1,200-2,500 for a 20-tonne unit from Shanghai to West Africa; a bad forwarder can cost 2-3x that. Ask the seller which forwarder will be used, then check the forwarder’s reputation on the Chinese export community forums (such as 福步外贸论坛).

4. How tight is the timeline? Under EXW, you can sometimes save 3-5 days because you control the export-clearance timing. Under FOB or CIF, you are dependent on the seller’s schedule. For a tight deadline, the term you can actually enforce is more important than the term that is technically cheapest.

How the price changes between terms

For a typical 20-tonne excavator shipped from Shanghai to Dakar, the differences are roughly: EXW is the base, FOB adds USD 1,000-1,500 (inland transport to port + export clearance + loading), CIF adds another USD 2,500-3,500 (ocean freight + marine insurance). The total gap between EXW and CIF is therefore USD 3,500-5,000 on a machine worth USD 35,000-50,000 — roughly 8-10% of the total deal value. The CIF markup is not a profit center for the seller; it is the actual cost of freight and insurance, and a good seller will itemize it on the invoice.

What we use at Asure

Most of our shipments go FOB at the Chinese port, with the buyer arranging the ocean leg through their own forwarder. For first-time buyers or buyers in markets where arranging local insurance is hard, we offer CIF with itemized freight and insurance on the commercial invoice. We do not default to EXW because most cross-border buyers do not want to manage the Chinese export-clearance paperwork. The term you choose is yours — the question is which cost and risk you are best placed to manage.

---

Incoterms 2020 is the current ICC standard. Specific terms should be confirmed in a contract that names the place of delivery, the point of cost transfer, and the point of risk transfer. For a specific deal, ask your commercial lawyer to confirm the term and the supporting contract language.